nCircle.com >> 360 Security

« Technical Versus Social Solutions | Main | SCADAGard SIG To Be Established »

Into Obscurity: The New Meaning of Blacklist

This is a tale of spam-blocking gone wrong. Spam blocking technology has a very noble mission on the surface -- protect Grandma from Nigerian scammers and Billy from seeing a grown man naked. It also eliminates a whole lot of time wasting and frustration, as well as virus and spyware-laden adds for "v1Agr a". And though I often suspect I am getting steganographic messages from Aliens, Trisha, I have given up trying to crack them. So, spam-filtering helps my life, personally.

Well, this is sort of a sinister and sad tale. That benign force of good, Bright Mail -- one of the main blockers of this oily, misspelled, vomit-in-e-mail-form -- has apparently been subverted in an insidious way.

It appears that somebody at Symantec added AfterDowningStreet.org to Bright Mail's blacklist, causing all of Comcast to stop sending e-mail containing this domain name in the content. This site is a political site that has been up for under two months and, incidentally, doesn't send spam. Suffice it to say that a lot of people don't like them for being a big pimple on the nose of our public discourse, or lack therof. I digress. I would love it if somebody from Symantec would tell me this is all a mistake or an accident. Could a third party intentionally spam others, using their domain, to get them on the blacklist? [How does Bright Mail get data for it's blacklists, for that matter? I honestly don't know.] Is it a conspiracy to deny them e-mail service? Did Comcast realize what was going on? Was it politically motivated and intentional? If it was the former, what a clever way to screw your enemies -- send a ton of spam as them and get them on Bright Mail's blacklist, so that the largest ISP in the country will blackhole their e-mail. Brilliant! If it was the latter, what a horrible precedent to set, squelching the modern day expression of lawful political expression.

Read More:

How Comcast Censors Political Content
Or Why My Comcast Horror Story Is Better Than Yours
by David Swanson

About

This page contains a single entry from the blog posted on July 20, 2005 10:33 PM.

The previous post in this blog was Technical Versus Social Solutions.

The next post in this blog is SCADAGard SIG To Be Established.

Many more can be found on the main index page or by looking through the archives.